Efficient vs. Effective

Posted on October 26th, 2010 by admin in Leadership, Miscellaneous, Productivity, Success

By Mike Myatt, Chief Strategy Officer, N2growth

Efficient vs. Effective – there is sometimes a very big difference between the two. So much so, that I have really come to cringe every time I hear the word efficiency. It’s not really that there is anything wrong with becoming more efficient, but what I find is that far too many executives major in the minors when it comes to efficiency. Let me ask you a question – Have you become so efficient that you’ve rendered yourself ineffective? At an organizational level have you focused so much on process improvements and incremental gains that you’ve failed to recognize opportunity and innovate? Are you efficient or effective, or do you know?

I really don’t have a problem with increasing efficiency so long as the tail doesn’t start wagging the dog. If efficiency starts diluting productivity rather than increasing it something is woefully amiss.  This is more than a semantical issue – it’s become a systemic problem with many individuals and organizations. As I’ve said many times before, things don’t always have to boil down to either/or types of decisions – not everything must end-up on the altar of sacrificial decisioning. With the proper perspective and focus it is quite possible to be both efficient and effective.

If you’re not tracking with me yet, ask yourself the following questions: Do you send an email when you should make a phone call, or worse, do you hide behind the phone when you should be face-to-face? Do your sophisticated screening processes do such a great job of filtering that it blinds you to new opportunities and critical information? Here’s the thing – if your desk is so clean you don’t have anything to work on then you might be focusing on the wrong thing…it might be time to make a bit of a mess.

What I want you to recognize is that sometimes the least efficient thing can be lead to the most productive outcome. A great example of this would be carving out time in your already too busy schedule to mentor someone in your organization with great potential. Clearly this endeavor will take time, and may not yield immediate results, but the payoff organizationally, relationally, culturally, and in terms of future contribution can be huge.

Bottom line…check your motivations. When you ever so efficiently cross something off your to-do list has it moved you farther away from, or closer to, putting points on the board? Better yet, are the items on your to-do list even the right items to begin with? Lastly, I’ll leave you with this reminder – leadership is not about how many emails, memos and transmittals are sent under your signature – it’s about relationships, service, and engagement.

As always, I welcome your thoughts in the comments section below…

Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Blogplay
 


  • http://www.emergentps.com brian

    Mike, *thank you* for making this very important distinction.

    A mouse running on a mousewheel can perfect their stride and reduce the amount of energy it takes to get "moving." If the goal is to get somewhere the mouse is efficiently ineffective.

    I can use a hand grenade to kill a mosquito. It ain't efficient but it sure is effective.

    Regards,

    brian
    @emergentinsight

  • pastortom2022

    Great thoughts Mike. The most difficult thing to measure is people results. As you said in the blog, when we choose to invest in people we may not receive immediate results. I am sure we produce more by giving ourselves to others than behind a closed door. Someone said "we never get holy living in a hole."

    Thanks again.

  • http://www.n2growth.com/blog/ mikemyatt

    Thanks Brian – I wish I would have used both of your illustrations. Well said. Thanks for stopping by Brian.

  • http://www.n2growth.com/blog/ mikemyatt

    Well said Tom – people are the name of the game when it comes to leadership. People are also messy, complicated, time consuming, and rarely efficient to lead. They are however clearly the investments that produce the greatest contributions. Thanks for sharing Tom.

  • susanmazza

    Excellent and important distinction Mike. The mechanistic world of the industrial age continues to have a grip on our belief system.

    I think we focus on efficiency because that gives us "permission" to focus on the things that we can control. Yet the things that make the most difference rarely fall into that category!

  • http://www.n2growth.com/blog/ mikemyatt

    Spot-on on Susan – The perception of control can be an illusion. It can also often become a destructive obsession when the focus points are incorrectly applied. Thanks for the insights Susan.

  • http://www.tanveernaseer.com/blog Tanveer Naseer

    Great post, Mike and I absolutely concur that there is a stark contrast in being efficient and being effective. I think what helps to delineate the two is asking the question what's the purpose behind your efforts?

    For many companies, employees are expected to complete given tasks or processes because 'that's what we've always done'. But if we focus instead on what the purpose is behind our efforts, suddenly it matters less if we're efficient in doing it if it ultimately contributes little to our organization's objectives.

    It's at that point that we can appreciate that encouraging efficiency is not as critical as encouraging effectiveness since it's the latter that will ultimately ensure we attain the goals we set out to reach.

  • http://www.n2growth.com/blog/ mikemyatt

    Hi Tanveer:

    Thanks for your insights. You brought up what is in my opinion one of the most dangerous statements in business: "that's what we've always done." I think your comments support the old axiom that distinguishes between doing things right and doing the right things. Thanks for stopping by Tanveer

  • http://www.validleadership.com James Castellano

    This is one of my favorites discussions. Efficiency deals with things. Being good at the utilization of commodities. Being effective is dealing with people. Helping them become good at utilizing things. We become efficient by being effective, period.

    For example, when we allow our people to work with boundaries instead of rules, they will find the best way to accomplish a task. We then teach this method to the others. They become efficient and we created an effective team.

  • http://www.n2growth.com/blog/ mikemyatt

    Hi James:

    Excellent points. In fact, the manner in which you frame your thoughts can also serve as a good rule of thumb in dealing with this argument. Thanks for stopping by James.

  • http://www.blog.jessicamalnik.com/2010/10/top-five-october-29/ Top Five: October 29 – Jessica Malnik

    [...] Efficient v. Effective (N2Growth) [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus